Dining Incognito
The Chestnut Room
Aline Sullivan
06/01/2004

The Homestead Inn has contributed much to the development of Greenwich, Conn., both in preserving its New England heritage and in keeping it on the cutting edge of great places to live. Behind the inn’s historic white clapboards, a vibrant decor unfolds that blends a European sensibility with an American freshness and a touch of Asian intrigue. English textiles and American solid cherry furniture artfully mix with pieces from China, Bali and India. The cuisine, however, is decidedly French.

For the locals and for an increasing number of Manhattanites, this is the place to see, dine and be seen. Or, for guests in the Chestnut Room, one of two private dining rooms at Thomas Henkelmann, the inn’s award-winning restaurant, it is a place to dine and not be seen. The room is not entirely private, but when privacy is desired, a screen can be placed at the room’s entrance, effectively blocking the view.

A side entrance allows diners to enter the Chestnut Room incognito by passing through the herb gardens and in through a set of French doors adjacent to the room. (You will have to brave the main dining room or entrance to the inn to access the restrooms.) Once ensconced, however, diners enjoy complete privacy.


Privacy has its place in Greenwich, home to one of the largest concentrations of hedge funds in the world, as well as an increasing number of bankers, lawyers and other executives who work locally. Long famous as one of the wealthiest suburbs in the United States, Greenwich is also now a commuting destination, and home to a fair number of celebrities, such as Mel Gibson, who work as and when they choose. 

Theresa Henkelmann and her husband, Thomas, who is the chef of the restaurant that bears his name, own the two properties. The restaurant is Thomas’ first taste of ownership after a career that began in his German home in the Black Forest and included the Auberge de l’Ill in Alsace and Auberge in Munich, both of which have three Michelin stars. He was then the head chef of Maurice at Le Parker Meridien in New York. Theresa describes her husband’s American debut in 1989 as he attempted to manage the staff knowing hardly a word of English: “He just kept repeating the only phrase he knew—the one from the Nike ad—Just do it.”


He has since picked up the language but has stayed true to his European roots in his cuisine, which was awarded four Mobil Stars in 2000. The food relies on regional American products but is really French, with dishes such as Hudson duck pâté, Maryland crab cakes with a tomato fondue and remoulade sauce and Maine lobster with an Andalouse sauce. It is rich and satisfying, but not heavy.

With its exposed brick and beams and a mural that depicts an idyllic Provençal village (the artist has painted in Thomas and Theresa among the villagers; look to the lower left corner), the Chestnut Room is more rustic than the elegant main dining rooms. Indeed, the room may be a bit too rustic for some tastes and possibly too dim on a beautiful day. But the wine-cellar feel will suit many others just fine, especially those who want to sample some of the restaurant’s 800-plus labels, and hosts looking for an intimate room. (Fourteen is the maximum, but the minimum of 10 would be much more comfortable.)

The Chestnut Room should be booked weeks, even months, in advance. Hosts are asked to select two appetizers, two entrées, a cheese course if they wish and two desserts. A menu will then be printed for the occasion and a sommelier will assist at the table. Lunch costs about $45 to $55 a person and dinner $65 to $75, excluding wine and other drinks. 

The Chestnut Room, Thomas Henkelmann
Homestead Inn

203.869.7500
www.homesteadinn.com