MNCs from the South enjoy a number of advantages when operating
in other emerging market economies. These include generally lower cost
structures, familiarity with difficulties that are often particular to emerging
markets gained from experience operating in their home markets, and their
production of items designed for the lower-income markets. Southern MNCs have
also tended to invest close to home in markets where there are shared ethnic or
cultural ties. But some multinational corporations are beginning to invest
further afield: Companies in Latin America and Asia have invested in Africa, and
Asia and Latin America are also swapping investment capital.In terms of sectors, South-South FDI flows have been dominated
by infrastructure and extractive industries. Southern MNCs have also been
expanding in the telecom sector, with Mexican, Russian and Egyptian companies
acquiring assets abroad. TOP VIEW Historically, foreign direct investment has flowed from North to
South. But that direction is changing. Emerging market multinationals of the
South are investing in other Southern economies, many of which share similar
challenges and opportunities. Some Southern multinationals are also reversing
the historical flow of FDI, investing in the North in their quest to capture
coveted skills, brands and production facilities. | There are a number of reasons why the extractive sector has led
the process. First, state-owned oil companies in emerging market economies have
access to reserves that can provide a natural source of long-term comparative
advantage. There has also been a stimulus to acquire access to supplies of
energy and other raw materials to fuel rapid economic growth and
industrialization in markets like China and India, which are net importers of
oil. This has created a need to look abroad to secure resource access.MNCs in Korea, Malaysia, Singapore and South Africa have a
well-established track record of investing abroad. Companies in others
countries, including Chile, Mexico, Brazil, China and India, have emerged as
players more recently. Geographically, outward FDI from emerging market
economies is now concentrated in Asia. Hong Kong has a higher FDI/Gross Fixed
Capital Formation (GFCF) ratio than most developed countries. Taiwan has a
higher FDI/GFCF ratio than the United States, Germany and Japan; its FDI mostly
flows to China. Chile and Malaysia have ratios higher than Germany and Japan.
Four of the five economies with the largest FDI stock are in Asia (Singapore,
Hong Kong, China and Taiwan), the other being Brazil. These five economies
account for more than 70 percent of the total FDI stock from the
South. Total foreign assets of the top 50 MNCs from the South climbed
to $249 billion in 2003 from $195 billion in 2002. The five largest MNCs
accounted for almost half of the total assets of the top 50. Hutchison Whampoa
of Hong Kong was the largest Southern MNC and alone accounted for 25 percent of
the total foreign assets held by the top 50. Asia dominated the top 50 with 39
enterprises. The other 11 companies are from South Africa, 4; Mexico, 4; and
Brazil, 3. Singapore and Hong Kong were the most important home economies, with
nine and 10, respectively, of the top 50 MNCs ranked by outward FDI. Taiwan had
eight. Southern multinationals have also been acquiring assets in the
developed world. This is evident in the recent acquisition of brands and
distribution capability, in particular by Chinese producers. Chinese
corporations TCL and Lenovo have acquired IBM, RCA and Thompson brands, allowing
them to short-circuit the lengthy brand- and loyalty-building process that
companies in Japan and Korea had to go through to increase global market
share. Southern MNCs have also invested to gain access to production
facilities or, in some cases, complete businesses from production through to
distribution capabilities. Mexican cement giant Cemex’s purchase of UK-based RMC
Group, another cement manufacturer, in 2005 was one such landmark transaction
for a company from the South. Brazilian brewer AmBev’s acquisition of Labatt in
Canada and South African brewer SABMiller’s purchase of a number of beer
companies in developed markets are other examples of companies acquiring and
building global brands. Russian natural gas company Gazprom raised concerns in
the UK last spring with its interest in UK gas utility Centrica.
There have also been a number of investments by MNCs in R&D
in the North to access technologies and knowledge to strengthen competitiveness
and move up the production value chain. Indian IT firms have been active in
this, investing in a number of developed markets. Even so, in net terms, the
flow is still in the other direction, and India and China have been important
beneficiaries of Northern investment in R&D.
|