Two-Pronged Approach Like most estate planning, this requires spouses to wrestle
with the difficult issue of how they want their assets divided after they die.
It is further complicated by the need to predict if, and for how long, they will
remain in the United States, particularly in the event of the death of one
spouse. Don Weigandt, a managing director with JPMorgan Private Bank in Los
Angeles, suggests that couples devise plans that allow them to decide later.
These strategies must be exceptionally flexible and include contingencies for
the surviving spouse to decide whether to continue to live in the United
States–as a citizen or noncitizen–or to return home. For example, one strategy
would enable an estate to pass to the surviving spouse through a revocable
trust, if the decision is made to become a U.S. citizen. If the surviving spouse
forgoes U.S. citizenship, the estate could pass through a QDOT.
"You always have to plan for the possibility your client is not
going to come back to you in a timely fashion if there has been some kind of big
change in the family," Weigandt says, "so you’re trying to draft to take into
account all the possibilities." If an international couple invests the time to
establish a plan of this nature, the surviving foreign spouse can enjoy nearly
the same advantages that the surviving U.S. spouse would, even if the spouse
forgoes U.S. citizenship.
Assets placed in QDOTs are shielded from estate taxes. As with
citizenship applications, foreign-born spouses may establish QDOTs up to nine
months after the death of a spouse. "The QDOT is really mandatory unless you’re
willing to pay an immediate estate tax," says Sharon Klein, vice president and
trust counsel with New York-based Fiduciary Trust Company International.
TAX BURDENS ON FOREIGN NATIONALS | NON-U.S. CITIZEN INVESTING IN THE U.S. Mr. Silva, a resident of another country who has never visited the U.S., dies
owning: | | value | Stock in U.S. corporations (Microsoft, Intel, etc.) | $3,000,000 | Lifetime exemption | $60,000 | U.S. estate tax (payable nine months after the date of death) | $1,227,800 | Net to heirs | $1,772,200 | | NON-U.S. CITIZEN LINVING IN THE U.S. | | value | Direct ownership of stock in U.S. corporations | $3,000,000 | Direct ownership of non-U.S. assets (in home country or another country) | $5,000,000 | Total estate | $8,000,000 | Lifetime exemption | $2,000,000 | U.S. estate tax | $2,760,000 | Net to heirs | $5,240,000 | Source: WTAS — Wealth and Tax Advisory Services, member HSBC
Group Marginal rate is currently 46%. Examples focus on U.S. federal taxes only and
do not take into account deductions for administrative expenses and other
regular deductions assuming the surviving spouse is not a U.S.
citizen. |
These trusts do have several drawbacks. Some couples balk at the thought of
handing over administrative control of their estate to a U.S.-based trustee,
most often of the corporate or institutional variety. "A lot of people do not
like the idea of having to have a relationship with a trustee, because you then
have to call that person every time you want a distribution," says Christopher Byrne, a managing director with HSBC’s Wealth
and Tax Advisory Services in New York. "That’s where people start to get upset
with it."Moreover, tapping the principle of a QDOT will trigger an
estate tax levy unless the beneficiary can prove financial hardship. It is also
difficult to hold real estate investments–especially those involving property
abroad–in these trusts. Finally, establishing a QDOT makes it more difficult to
perform any additional estate planning. A strategy that relies on life insurance gets around some of
these problems. The couple places cash in an irrevocable trust and uses it to
fund the premiums on enough life insurance to cover the projected amount of
estate tax. If structured properly, the death benefit of the life insurance paid
to the trust will not be subject to estate tax, Byrne explains. A term-life
policy might work best, especially for foreign-born spouses who plan on staying
in the U.S. only for a fixed period of time, he adds. Couples may also transfer assets during their lifetime. The
U.S. citizen may currently give $120,000 per year, indexed to inflation, to a
nonresident alien spouse without facing gift tax penalties, notes Bill Forsyth,
managing director and senior fiduciary counsel with Bessemer Trust in New York.
Other methods to avoid gift taxes, such as grantor retained annuity trusts, can
also be useful. "You would try to do as much lifetime planning as you could," he
notes. Couples residing in community property states have an
advantage. These states, such as California, Texas and Arizona, already consider
spouses to own equal shares in one another’s earned assets, even if one spouse
has a much higher income than the other.
|