![]() |
||||||||||||||
| Feature | ||||||||||||||
| Globalization Survival Guide
Dennis T. Jaffe and Jackie Cooperman 02/01/2006 |
||||||||||||||
Few words unnerve family business leaders more than
"globalization." But with NAFTA and the World Trade Organization breaking down
trade barriers, the approval of the Central America-Dominican Republic Free
Trade Agreement nearly at hand, and a Free Trade Area of the Americas in the
works, many family businesses face a host of new overseas competitors.
Despite the unfair presumption that family businesses are often
parochial enterprises, however, many have not only successfully defended their
companies against international competitors, but expanded out of their home
markets to exploit the opportunities afforded by globalization. In fact, there
is evidence that the family business model may be uniquely suited to overcoming
the challenges inherent in this inevitable shift.
Family businesses often have close-knit executive teams that can identify
competitive threats and then act quickly to counter them. They are also
accustomed to forging relationships with–rather than simply transacting
with–partners and vendors; this gives them a leg up overseas, where close
contact and tactful communication often open doors. Finally, family members with
a vested interest in the business may be more willing than hired managers to
invest the time, effort and capital needed to learn about foreign markets by
traveling and making local contacts.
Since 1918, Atlas has manufactured devices that gauge the damaging effects of light, water and temperature on goods ranging from textiles to steering wheels. Atlas’ devices and the chemicals used in them have been the basis of a profitable and growing–albeit unglamorous–business for several generations.
"When we established a European headquarters, we were able to get our local organization to work with top chemists to change the European national standards so we could become competitive," says Bill, 69, who is passing company control to his three adult children. With trade pathways open, his father made it a point to establish personal relationships on the Continent, traveling often to visit Atlas’ independent sales reps. "He saw other companies getting into this area," Bill recalls, "and felt that he had to be proactive in order to control our destiny."
The core business is still owned by the Lane family. Bill’s three children–Gigi, Russell and Chuck, plus son-in-law Jim–hold executive positions. The company comprises a textile division, with 240 employees, and a weathering group, with 350, on three continents. But Atlas’ global expansion rests on finding foreign partners, installing local managers (the company has never moved an American manager to Europe) and aggressively buying competitors. Its European companies are run with operating committees that include Europeans, Bill says. As in the 1940s, Atlas handles overseas issues with a level of tact some Americans might find extraordinary. Russell, Bill’s older son, earned a master’s degree from Garvin School for International Management in Glendale, Ariz., and now runs U.S. operations for Atlas’ weathering division. "In Europe, if you want to make a structural change, the walls and regulations are amazing," he says. "We are told, ‘You can’t do this, you can’t do that, or you face big fines or jail.’ It really limits our flexibility." The Lanes have also worked to overcome the cultural gap that often exists when Americans deal with their foreign counterparts. "There are issues, making sure that you approach a customer or employee in a way that isn’t offensive," Russell says. "We Americans tend to be very direct, but a lot of cultures don’t like that." Bill remembers an embarrassing moment during a business dinner in Germany. A Frenchman casually asked him if he spoke any languages. "I said some Spanish, which I had taken in high school–and he began to speak to me in fluent Spanish," Bill says. "I learned my lesson. I do make it a point to read up on a country before I go there, and even to make a feeble attempt to learn a few phrases, which is appreciated and helps in relationship building. The good news is that the business world is becoming more Anglicized in many ways with international trade growing."
Chuck often speaks with his father, sister and brother in Chicago. Atlas manufactures weathering division products in the United States and Germany, and the company may ponder moving more of that production to China. But the family will not gamble on that until they have resolved the quality-control issues and are more comfortable with their operation. Still, additional investment in Asia seems to be in Atlas’ long-term future if the company aims to become dominant in these lower-cost markets. "Does this take away from what we are doing here? Perhaps," Bill admits. "Have we lost jobs for the U.S., the UK and Europe? Probably. On the other hand, we have increased our potential revenues because we have become more cost-competitive in our fastest-growing market, Asia. If we double sales–and we are on track to do that–we will make a significant shift in our bottom line, and that will create a stronger company, which should be good for the entire organization." –Dennis T. Jaffe Andrea Illy, the third generation of family behind Illycaffè, sees his efforts to bring Italian espresso drinking to Asia as "sort of missionary work." With his Brioni suit and Bulgari cuff links, the understated 41-year-old looks more like a movie star than a missionary. But coffee has been something of a divine calling for the Illys since Andrea’s grandfather, Francesco, founded the company in Trieste in 1933 and became the first Italian coffee purveyor to sell his brand throughout the country. Andrea’s father, Ernesto, who stepped down as CEO in 1994, dons a lapel pin of interlocking espresso cups signifying his belief that espresso is meant to be shared. He also carries a silver tasting spoon designed by another son, Riccardo. The Illys make a single roast, 100 percent Arabica-bean espresso now sold through retailers and Illy cafes in 130 countries. But, for his family’s success, Andrea intends to take the company to another level in Asia. In Illycaffè’s most ambitious expansion to date, Andrea is making an especially concerted effort in India. Although the company has long bought coffee beans from Indian growers, this is a nation that consumes 200,000 tons of tea a year and a mere 15,000 tons of coffee, according to estimates from Euromonitor International. Andrea hopes to boost Indian consumption of his family’s product over the next five years from its current 30 tons a year to as much as 1,000 tons by exporting a very continental European sense of coffee. Illycaffè and its Indian partner, Fresh & Honest Café (F&H), will invest $20 million to add 120 coffee bars to the existing 130 that F&H operates under the name Barista, and to install 6,000 Illy espresso machines in India’s leading hotels and restaurants. Andrea is aware that to succeed he might have to refine the coffee experience so that it fits another culture’s expectations in some thus-far-unknown way. "We have to understand all cultures for the sake of customer satisfaction. We cannot do everything the Italian way," he says.
This impressive growth rests, inevitably, on strategic decisions of Asian partners. He has a nonfamily partner with ambitions at least equal to his in V. Srinivasan, the head of F&H, who has told the local media about how important the partnership is to his company’s desires to "offer the complete range of coffee experience to our customers and realize our aggressive growth plans."
"You need to study chemistry to understand the complexity of life and of the world," says Ernesto, a spry octogenarian who will happily expound for hours on the scientific properties of the perfect espresso. It was under his reign that Illy cracked the U.S. market. "I had this conviction that if you wanted to be global, you had to be in the United States," Ernesto adds. "In the beginning, I had some difficulty convincing my family." Today the entire family sits on the board, but Andrea also depends for expertise on several outside directors, including a prominent Italian banker, a business professor and the CEO of Lloyd Adriatico insurance. He maintains that ideas from outsiders can be as stimulating as a jolt of espresso itself. Already, he says, "I think we’re less Italian and more global than when my grandfather led the company." –Jackie Cooperman Russell Lewis knew that he had an innovative product when he founded Rhino Linings in 1988. But he was also aware that he needed to create a network to distribute and support his product, and that if he wanted to expand, he would need a global reach.
Rhino Linings manufactures equipment and products in San Diego and Louisiana and sells them to its dealers around the world. The company and its dealers are almost wholly symbiotic.
But when Lewis initially ventured overseas with Rhino Linings, he stumbled out of the gate. He first tried to export a traditional dealer-distributor model, he says. "This did not work. They would sell one product, but not really support it and get the follow-up business. We found it was not enough to sell [them equipment] without providing ongoing support." Lewis had to shift his American way of thinking about how products and services are marketed to empower his overseas dealers. "We learned that the U.S. is very transactional; people don’t need to know us to buy our product," he explains. "In other countries, sales are more relationship driven; they don’t buy until they know you. We had to learn how to build relationships in these countries. It has taken a while for us to learn how to do this, but we are stronger for it now."
Indeed, Lewis’ globalization strategy rests not in exploiting cheaper capital costs overseas, but in creating collaborative partnerships in which both the parent company and the dealer, no matter how far flung, benefit. Today Rhino Linings’ trademark is registered in some 120 nations, and Lewis devotes the money and time to bolster his dealers’ efforts. "It is hard to service a dealer in another country," Lewis admits. "Our global environment is very much like a family business, with incredible loyalty and commitment to each other. We provide support, and they help us build the Rhino Linings brand on the local level." Lewis plans to continue to invest heavily in his overseas dealers, in terms
of capital, time and expertise. He knows all too well that international
business is not a one-size-fits-all venture. "We must have employees and dealers
that believe in our products," he says. "We must continue to analyze the
differences in each global environment and adapt to these differences. Running a
business is not just about selling a product; we must be able to support our
dealers. This is what makes Rhino Linings successful." –Dennis T.
Jaffe |