 |
When Patty Bloomer’s husband fell ill with cancer, she took control of the finances that they had
managed together for decades. But before she could make any investment
decisions, she first had to educate the conservative banker the couple then used
about their working relationship.
Bloomer, of Binghamton, N.Y., recalls receiving a letter from
her banker telling her how he planned to manage her assets. As a person who came
of age when societal mores encouraged women to defer to men regarding financial
matters, Bloomer, a member of the local Junior League, had long confronted
sexism of this sort. She picked up the phone and told the banker that she was
not going to follow his plan. Then she gave him some orders of her own. She
wanted to meet with her banker and her husband to discuss what to do with their
investments—and that is exactly what happened.
"Bankers always felt that they could manage your money for you,
and you had very little say," Bloomer recalls. "Over the years, I have made it
very clear to them that they invest the money, but they and I are the ones who
make the decisions."
Bloomer’s experience reflects two growing trends: the
increasing importance of affluent women as a client base for advisors and
financial institutions, and the need for fresh approaches by financial
professionals who work with these women. Between 1996 and 1998, the number of
affluent women—with investable assets of at least $3 million—in the U.S.
increased by 68 percent, compared with a 36 percent increase in the number of
wealthy men, according to the study Women of Wealth by Russ Alan Prince
and Hannah Shaw Grove. The report surveyed 743 women who had a combined $4.85
billion in net assets and a combined net worth of $17.81 billion; it was cited
in a presentation by Lisa Gray, CEO of Graymatter Strategies, which assists
advisors serving affluent individuals and families.
TOP VIEW Demographic shifts are creating a growing number of affluent women, and the financial services industry is rushing to serve them. Some advisors offer these women little more than patronizing platitudes,
while others pitch programs that range from financial spas to seminars focused
on wealth and happiness. The most suc-cessful relationships, however, seem to develop when these women become well educated on the issues surrounding investing, wealth transference and philanthropy. |
The number of women who own large portfolios will only grow as
the baby boomer population ages. Over the next decade, more than 7 million
entrepreneurs will liquidate their businesses, representing more than $10
trillion in wealth, according to data cited by Elizabeth Bloomer Nesvold,
Bloomer’s daughter and a managing director and partner of New York–based
Cambridge International Partners, a mergers and acquisitions advisory firm
specializing in financial services. About half of these business owners will be
women—many of whom will hold large amounts of cash for the first time in their
lives. Given that men typically die at an earlier age, many more women will be
left to manage their family’s wealth after their husbands pass. "The dynamic is
changing. Not only are we going to see more women in control, but women live a
lot longer," Nesvold says. "There is going to be a need to understand their
issues—in the context of executives who have very busy lives and women in
transition, let’s say, widows."
Group Dynamics Focusing on women as a group does not suggest that they need
different financial information than men. Prosperous women and the advisors who
have built successful relationships with them are leery of sweeping
generalizations that overlook the diversity of experience and the knowledge—that
many women bring to financial discussions today.
But some common themes are emerging. While women require the
same type of in-depth financial data that men do, many women prefer a different
kind of communication style. This encompasses all phases of the process, from
the marketing pitch to the working relationship. When selecting an advisor,
women often emphasize building a long-term partnership; men tend to focus more
on new trends in investing that an advisor might introduce. Many men tend to
view increasing their wealth as an end in itself, while women often perceive
their funds in a broader context—as a means to be independent, care for children
or make philanthropic gifts, for example. Lastly, while men and women both want
details on portfolio performance, many women go a step further and take an
interest in the thought process behind an advisor’s investment choice. "I like a
company that provides education," says Sandra Haslinger of Akron, Ohio. "They
sit down with you and explain what they’re doing, what it’s all about; they have
recommended reading and have someone in the company who writes about the
philosophies." Haslinger found herself suddenly having to navigate the world
of financial advisors when her husband died in the mid-1990s. As in many
affluent families of her generation, Haslinger had left the management of
finances up to her spouse. She did not even sit in on meetings with their
advisor.
After her husband’s death, she began searching for a new team
of professionals, including a financial advisor, estate planning attorney and an
accountant, who better fit her personally. A friend recommended her son, who
worked at a large bank. Haslinger met with him out of courtesy, but had
misgivings about choosing a bank rather than a boutique firm because of what she
perceived to be high levels of turnover at institutions. Her instincts proved
correct when he left the bank a few years later. Instead, she chose to work with
Lydian Wealth Management, a financial services firm based in Rockville, Md. She
liked CEO Steve Lockshin’s personal input and his availability.
Haslinger’s desire for a deeper relationship is common among
female clients, says Kaycee Krysty, president and CEO of Seattle-based
investment firm Laird Norton Tyee. "Men like to hear, ‘What I have for you is a
convertible bond arbitrage with a tax efficiency overlay,’" Krysty says.
"Traditionally, men are not going to ask, but women will, ‘That sounds good, but
what the heck is that?’ They really want to understand what’s behind the
numbers."
The Marketing Message Like Haslinger, Kathryn Hinsch asked friends for referrals when
she and her husband were preparing to change advisors. Hinsch, founding director
and board president of think tank Women’s Bioethics Project in Seattle, wanted a
full-service firm that would help her and her husband do more than just put
their money into funds and funds of funds. The couple was also thinking about
broader projects, including trusts for their nieces.
Hinsch has clear ideas about the kind of marketing that repels
her. As a member of several nonprofit boards, she often is approached by
financial professionals who have attended a charity function for one of her
organizations. Hinsch views this tactic as a very superficial way to try to make
a connection, and says that she will not trust someone with her finances just
because they happen to meet. Nor was she impressed by a trip to Seattle’s
exclusive, decidedly masculine stomping ground, the Rainier Club, where
financial advisors tried to wow her. Hinsch felt alienated by the setting, as
well as condescended to; if she wanted to spend her time in the Rainier’s
Jacobean-style mansion, she and her husband would just join the club. She is
also put off by soft marketing that ties financial matters to feel-good
pampering such as a spa treatment. To Hinsch, that kind of pairing minimizes
women’s concern about money and economics. "My observation of the financial
services industry and its marketing is that in both trivial and profound ways,
it is missing the boat in how it markets to women," she says.
On the trivial side, Hinsch decries the male-oriented
aspirational advertisements found in many magazines. An older man may relate to
an image of a gray-haired patriarch and his trophy wife, but Hinsch does not.
She also notes a lack of financial services advertisements in women’s magazines
that target highly educated, successful readers.
More pointedly, Hinsch believes that financial services firms
often fail to address the reality of women’s lives today. She points out that
women are likely to be divorced, become second or third wives and to outlive
their spouses or former spouses. These firms often fail to convey an
understanding of the fact that many women view money differently than men. For
example, the concept of legacy continues to serve as a prominent selling point
for financial services firms. But Hinsch believes that many women in their 40s
and 50s, faced with lessening responsibility at home, take this opportunity to
consider what they want to do for the world, rather than what legacy they hope
to leave for their offspring. "Women in my situation, I think of them as women
of means with dreams," Hinsch says. "Just changing the language and how you
approach it . . . really gets down to understanding the psychology of how women
think about their lives and about money." Having crossed off advisors who pitched to her as if she were
in the old-boys’ network, along with those who tried a superficial approach,
Hinsch drew on her own networking base in Seattle. She met Krysty, then a CPA,
in the early 1980s when the two were part of a leadership organization called
Business and Professional Women. Krysty went on to head Laird Norton Tyee.
Hinsch later contacted the firm, and she and her husband chose to work with
Krysty and her team. "I had known Kaycee and her reputation in the community,"
Hinsch says.
Hinsch’s concept of "women of means with dreams" resonates with
Haslinger. She says that managing her financial files and paperwork can be
time-consuming, but her successful stewardship of her family’s portfolio allows
her to fulfill some dearly held ambitions. Since 2002, she has donated $4
million to create the Haslinger Family Pediatric Palliative Care Center at the
Akron Children’s Hospital. Haslinger chose palliative care partly because of her
experience as a nursing student working with a terminally ill child. She hopes
the program will become a model for hospitals nationwide. She has also funded a
permanent gallery at the renovated Akron Art Museum, set to open in July, and
made a large gift to the school her children attended. "I’ve been able to make
some difference in the community," she says. "Being able to provide end-of-life
care for children was kind of like coming full circle."
Information Influx Marketing materials continue to fill Haslinger’s mailbox, and
she has noticed an increase in cold calls. She is happy with her team, however,
and ignores the pitches. But more affluent women can expect to be the targets of
additional marketing campaigns from financial services firms. Marketers fully
realize the compelling demographic trends and are attempting to determine how
best to reach this underserved client base. Firms now approach women with soft
sells, including financial spas where financial information is combined with
pedicures and massages, as well as with workshops and retreats.
Glenmede Trust, a wealth advisory firm, offers a series of
financial education seminars for women. The programs began last year in five
Eastern cities. Most of the attendees were between 50 and 70 years old, and
about one-quarter of them had already faced an event that caused them to come
into control of their finances, according to Nina Cohen, managing director of
the firm’s philanthropic advisory services. The seminars were born out of a
request for financial education from Glenmede’s female clients. This spring,
Glenmede, based in Philadelphia, plans to follow up with more-focused sessions
for groups of about 20 women. Topics may include setting up a private
foundation and raising financially responsible children.
Financial planner Karen Altfest, vice president of L.J. Altfest
& Co. in New York, tries a softer pitch, presenting financial education as a
means of taking care of oneself. In the past, she had trouble finding enough
interested women to attend one financial spa a year, but she now hosts about
three events per month.
Other financial advisors take a broader approach to the idea of
financial education for prosperous women—and the men who care about them.
Lockshin of Lydian Wealth Management has collaborated with educational group
Wealthbridge Partners on a new retreat series complete with its own website,
wealthandhappiness.com. Lockshin focuses the program on the nonfinancial issues
surrounding wealth, such as how to pass family values to children. He plans four
retreats this year, in Washington, D.C., Seattle, New York and Palm Beach, for
as many as 100 participants per session. "Addressing those issues typically
brought up more by a female client than a male client helped drive us to this,"
Lockshin says.
Catherine Curan is a senior correspondent for Worth. Illustration by Tim Bower. Additional Information
Continuing Education |