The safest investments are founded on a feature that may seem
counterintuitive when applied to something that fell out of the sky: provenance.
Collectors strive to attain so-called named meteorites; some hope to amass at
least one piece from each named meteorite. Names are given based on where a
meteorite fell or was found. In 1492, the residents of Ensisheim, France, shaken
by a loud explosion, discovered a 280-pound meteorite and began cutting it into
pieces. Many of these shards have found their way into museums and private
collections; a 120-pound section remains in Ensisheim. Other famous meteorite
families include Sikhote-Alin from a 1947 Russian impact and prehistoric Gibeon
specimens from Namibia. For collectors, a piece of Ensisheim–which might come up
in auction once a year–or another well-known meteorite has the best chance of
appreciating because they are well-documented. | BECAUSE OF its singular, uncharacteristic shape, this natural
sculpture from outer space, recovered in Namibia, is valued at $30,000. | Alternately, meteorites from the Sahara that are collected with
little or no regard for documentation are referred to as NWAs, as in Northwest
Africa, or more derisively, Not Worth Anything. They lack a sense of place, as
well as the intriguing histories that often surround a named meteorite, and
consequently rarely figure into valuable collections.Beyond their earthly landings, specimens are also divided by their
composition. There are three broad categories of meteorites: stony, iron and
stony-iron. Most meteorites proffered for sale are stony specimens called
chondrites that are simply bits of asteroids from the belt between Mars and
Jupiter. They cost a few cents or few dollars per gram. Rare specimens that are
either remarkable in their appearance or in their origin sell from $10 to $20
per gram up to hundreds or thousands of dollars per gram. Pallasites, a type of
stony-iron meteorite popular with collectors, look like jeweled stained-glass
panels when sliced. Because meteorites often seem unexceptional, collectors must
be sure that what they purchase is genuine. Market insiders, however, claim that
outright fraud is rare. "I find it interesting that almost everywhere in natural history there are
fakes . . . [but] I haven’t really heard of a problem with someone selling a
stone and saying it’s a meteorite," says Herskowitz, who also handles fossils
and gems. Dealers insist that meteorites are so freely accessible and the
community so small that illicit trade is simply not worth the risk. VALUE JUDGMENT:
Meteorite collecting has
moved from the quirky surroundings of astronomy clubs and mineral shows to the
high end of the collectibles market. The most passionate collectors literally
chase meteorites to the ends of the earth. While values have stagnated in recent
years because of a deluge of specimens from North Africa, the problem finally
seems to be subsiding. The finest examples are still worth far more than their
weight in gold. | Divide and Conquer Even so, collectors are advised to keep to a reputable chain of
ownership because meteorite shards spread faster than juicy gossip. Scientists
who analyze a new meteorite to establish its chemical content require the finder
to sacrifice a portion of the mass. After the Meteoritic Society, the world
standards body, approves the find, the specimen may be cut into many smaller
pieces, whose new owners may further divide them. Chipping a small piece off a
large block for chemical analysis may be palatable when a rock is found, but the
expense and loss of valuable material becomes increasingly unfeasible as
specimens become smaller.
To find reputable sources and gain access to the best
meteorites on the market, Schwade recommends building a collection with the
assistance of a good dealer. Buying from a dealer tends to be more affordable
than buying a piece at auction. Many collectors augment their assortment by
bartering. While one would never dream of cutting up a Picasso or a Duesenberg,
it is standard practice with meteorites. "Finding a totally new meteorite,
slicing it up and exchanging with museums is an excellent way to grow a
collection," says Schwade, who has traded with the British Museum of Natural
History and the Smithsonian. Scientific institutions win much of the spoils of official meteorite
expeditions, notably to Antarctica, so they often have a wealth of samples.
Collectors sometimes trade one of their specimens to a museum in exchange for one of its pieces. Institutions are not as generous as they
were a few years ago, however, when many gave away very valuable specimens as
trades for pieces of the first Martian and lunar samples to come out of the
Sahara, only to have the value of the new specimens drop precipitously. Unfortunately, even though collectors may own treasured pieces
that are worthy of the world’s best museums, securing them also requires
museumlike considerations. Climactic concerns must be addressed: Meteorites will
rust in humid climates and require special containers. Collectors must also be
wary of thieves. These highly portable rocks are prohibitive to insure because
underwriting companies are unfamiliar with them, and meteorites acquired in
trades are difficult to value. Thus, collectors rely on physical security
measures; they have good home security systems and keep their highly prized
specimens in vaults or safety deposit boxes. "Insurance companies do not
understand the value of meteorites," Schwade points out, "and they seem to
charge higher rates than they would for things they understand, like jewelry and
art." Lee Gimpel is a business and technology writer based in
Richmond, Va.
Photography courtesy Macovich Collection.
Additional Information
Prospects for Prospectors
|