 |
A century after the black plague decimated florence, the Medicis began to rebuild it. By the mid-1400s, the city was
the focus of the Italian Renaissance. Today, patrons in the U.S. are
reinvigorating cities and entire regions with their wealth, philanthropy,
political connections and, most importantly, their vision for improving the
world one community at a time. Ed Bass of the Bass oil fortune foresaw a lively
urban center in Fort Worth’s seedy downtown, and made it happen.
Paul Allen’s biomedical research center
transformed Seattle’s gritty South Lake Union district. Eli Broad spent years
working to create a Champs-Ely- sees in Los Angeles. These visionaries begin
with altruistic aims, but many soon find that reinvigorating a neighborhood
becomes an all-consuming pursuit. Even if the citizenry cheers them on, missteps
can occur. In 1999, Jerry Frautschi, a Madison, Wis., businessman and the
husband of Pleasant Rowland, creator of American Girl dolls who sold the company
to Mattel, donated $205 million to build a performing arts hall, Overture
Center, in downtown Madison. He also created an endowment to keep the center
from becoming a drain on taxpayers. But he conceived his plan in the bull market
of the late 1990s, counting on the endowment to earn annual returns of roughly 9
percent. Today, the town is abuzz over how exactly the Overture Center will
finance its operating budget beyond 2007.
A benefactor who takes on the status quo may also find himself
going to battle. Critics may decry his efforts as a power play—or one driven by
profit. Supporters will appreciate his ability to entertain their ideas, while
detractors will complain that local changes should come from the grass roots,
not the gated communities.
In the early 20th century, many cities boasted private cadres
of power brokers who made things happen. But beginning in the 1960s, such
tightly held power fell under public suspicion, and cities scrambled to make
their governments more open to the citizenry. More recently, local officials and
voters decry the fact that regional economies fall under the control of
multinational retail conglomerates. They are gaining a new appreciation for
local entrepreneurs who want to give back.
Impoverished areas certainly deserve philanthropic capital. But saving
something closer to home requires more than money. These projects demand
hundreds of hours of face time with the community. Civic lights must be able to
remind their neighbors that this is their home, too, and they want to see it
performing at its best. Eli Broad strives to elevate the heart of the City of the Angels to truly grand heights.
For four decades, Eli Broad,
founder and former chairman of KB Home and SunAmerica, has been one of those Los
Angeles transplants who laments his adopted city’s lack of a true core and
soul—a downtown where artists, office workers, shoppers, diners and residents
gravitate at all hours. Six years ago, Broad decided to stop hoping for city
plans that never materialized and put his own money into motion. He invited his
friend Richard Riordan, the city’s mayor at the time, and a group of county
supervisors to his home to talk about finally transforming the downtown area
along Grand Avenue.
‘‘ I envision it as a place where people from all parts of the
community will feel comfortable being with each other.’’ | That kind of transformation has been a dream ever since Dorothy
Buffum Chandler, by doggedly raising funds and cajoling the city’s leaders,
brought the Music Center into being in the 1960s. In the ensuing years, downtown
L.A. added museums and performance spaces, but lacked the kind of urban élan
Broad finds in what he calls the three other great cities—New York, London and
Paris.
"I saw all this city land and county land, and no one was doing
anything," Broad says. "And if we left it up to the city officials, I’m not sure
what would have happened other than piecemeal, unplanned development."
Grand Avenue cuts through the Bunker Hill area, the city’s core
where City Hall, U.S. District Court and the Civic Center stand within blocks of
each other. The neighborhood has come a long way from its seedier period in the
1950s, when once-grand Victorian homes stood in disrepair. Broad has been one
of many to support cultural growth in this area. He chaired the capital campaign
to build the Walt Disney Concert Hall, which opened in 2003, and contributed $18
million of his own money. Still, as he saw it, the area needed more attractions,
along with housing and retail to create the kind of mixed-use development urban
planners prize.
So Broad gathered area officials and constituent groups,
including representatives from the Music Center and the Catholic Archdiocese,
and formed the Grand Avenue Committee, which he funded with $200,000. The group
became the starting place to build support among politicians and community
activists. The first challenge was to get the county and city to cooperate and
create a joint-powers authority to oversee the project.
"It’s a known fact that the city and county do not get along,"
Broad says. In multiple lunches and meetings, facilitated in part through the
committee, Broad convinced three mayors and numerous county supervisors and city
council members of the plan’s merit. While they initially showed reluctance,
Broad says that he believes the politicians were willing to consider his ideas
because he had local credibility.
"I’ve been in this city now for 40 years—they know that I don’t
hound them for commercial purposes. They know I have a history of doing good, so
to speak, whether it’s in education or the arts," Broad says. "They know I’m
generous, they know I’ve helped them to modest degrees during their political
campaigns, so I have access, and they’ll listen."
Still, at times the project seemed on the verge of collapse. At
one point, county and city politicians argued over who would approve it. Broad
stepped in to broker a deal that called for simultaneous votes. On February 13,
the county board of supervisors and the city council officially approved the
project, granting a 99-year lease to the development firm Related Companies. In
early March, Broad stepped down as chairman of the Grand Avenue Committee to
focus on other projects.
When completed (construction will take place in three phases
over an estimated four years), the $2 billion Grand Avenue project will include
400,000 square feet of retail shops, 2,600 housing units, a five-star Mandarin
Oriental Hotel and a park. Five hundred of the housing units will be set aside
for moderate-income residents. Related Companies, headed by New York housing
magnate and philanthropist Stephen M. Ross, will bear the financial cost of the
construction. Broad’s personal contributions have primarily been organizational.
He is considering, however, contributing to the park, and hopes that others will
follow.
Broad is pleased that the endeavor is backed by 21 civic
groups. "We’ve never seen such community support for a project," he says. Along
the way, however, critics have attacked both the plan and Broad. Some groups
questioned whether the development would benefit only the wealthy. Others
pointed out an irony that Broad profited from building moderately priced houses
throughout the West, contributing to urban flight, yet the Grand Avenue project
celebrates the opposite: civic renewal.
Broad says he ignores such disparagement. "I was very proud of
the fact that we created KB Home and built hundreds of thousands of homes where
people wanted to buy them—which was not downtown."
Today, visiting the area, it is apparent how much the existing
attractions want for context. The park and greens will connect landmark
buildings with an aim of weaving together commercial and residential uses.
The February 14 front page of the Los Angeles Times
announcing the nearly unanimous votes featured a large photo of Broad and
councilman Bill Rosendahl celebrating six years of hard work building a
coalition, under a banner headline: "Grand Avenue Project Passes Go."
"I envision it as a place where people from all parts of the community—whether west side, east side, south side, the Valley—will feel
comfortable being with each other, which is what we need," Broad
says.
Ann Goodnight and her husband, Jim, confront issues in the Research Triangle.
Ann Goodnight and her husband, Jim, both graduates of North Carolina State University, were college
sweethearts in the 1960s when the state’s Research Triangle was beginning to
show promise. Ann studied political science, while Jim eyed a future in
technology. He received a bachelor of science degree in applied mathematics in
1965 and joined NASA’s Apollo program for a year before returning home to earn
his doctorate. In 1976, he launched a software company, SAS Institute, in an era
when tech behemoths—including Cisco Systems, IBM and Nortel Networks—were moving
into the area.
 | | (Photograph by David Sciabarasi.) | "We really owe our state," Ann says. She is fully aware that as
Jim and she benefited from the technology boom and an influx of affluent new
residents, North Carolina was simultaneously experiencing economic
upheaval—losing its traditional furniture, textile and tobacco industries and
seeing nearly 13 percent of its residents slip below the poverty line, according
to state government statistics. The Goodnights, whose net worth is estimated at
$4.1 billion to $4.5 billion, according to Forbes’ latest tally, are uncontested
as the richest people in the state.
Their home and SAS headquarters are both located in Cary, the
Raleigh suburb known for having more PhDs per capita than any American city with
a population of at least 75,000. In recent years, the name Cary has inspired a
local joke; it’s an acronym for Containment Area for Relocated Yankees.
‘‘ We really owe our state.’’ | Ann is quick to point out that in the Research Triangle and to
the area to its north, schools, hospitals and other infrastructure have not
quite caught up with the ongoing population boom. For their part, the Goodnights
have contributed time and money aimed at upgrading the public schools. They have
become alarmed by statistics showing that 37 percent of North Carolina high
school students drop out before graduation. This school year saw an influx of
nearly 8,000 new students in the Wake County public school system. Because Ann
had spoken out for increased school funding in the past and had founded a
high-tech private school, Cary Academy, she was not surprised when she received
a call last year before the start of the fall semester from the county
commissioner. He asked her to help sponsor a school construction bond proposal
that would fund 17 new schools, along with renovations and repairs for 113
others. As cochair of Friends of Wake County, a group formed to push for the
measure, Ann helped lead a successful effort to pass the $970 million
plan—supported by 53 percent of voters last November. Jim backed the proposal as
well, emailing 4,000 SAS employees urging them to vote yes.
Controversy dogged the campaign, as residents worried over what
the measure might mean for their tax bills. On Election Day, a reporter asked
Ann about poll results showing a significant number of voters opposed to the
initiative. She admitted that she was frustrated that people "don’t get it"—an
off-the-cuff response she now regrets. One of the opponent groups accused the
Goodnights of having a vested interest in the proposal because, as Cary
landowners, they stood to benefit from regional growth. These criticisms do not
seem to faze Ann. "Their argument was so far-fetched; it didn’t hold water, it
didn’t add up, it wasn’t consistent," she says. "They were just
panicking—throwing anything they could into the mix to keep voters confused and
doubtful."
In February, local residents learned that a company backed by
Jim plans to sell 108 acres to the school board at a 168 percent profit. Jim,
who had no knowledge of the deal, according to his business associates, has
since told his representatives to return any of his profit to taxpayers.
Four years ago, the Goodnights began crusading for
infrastructure of a different nature when they decided that Wake County needed a
four-star hotel for its steady stream of visitors. They reasoned that such a
hotel would also enhance the city’s social and cultural life while creating new
jobs. Though they had no experience in the industry, they called senior
executives at the Four Seasons and Ritz-Carlton with their proposal. Jim pointed
out that many companies were expanding in the area. The rebuff they received
came as something of a shock. "I remember the Four Seasons head guy told me,
‘You know, if we got a hotel down there and assigned our managers to it, they
would think they had been demoted,’" Ann says.
Rather than scrap the plan, the Goodnights chose to build the
hotel themselves. They used the Four Seasons in San Francisco as a model and set
aside land on the SAS campus. First they picked a site that abutted a
residential area, but the adjacent community was no less opposed than the hotel
chains had been. So they moved their hotel a mile away, to a spot that Ann says
she now likes better. In January, they opened the 150-room Umstead Hotel. No one
is yet willing to predict the plan’s commercial success or whether the
Goodnights’ estimation of their area’s demand for a four-star hotel and spa is
accurate—let alone their promises of local economic growth.
Ann’s latest philanthropic and educational effort is an
outreach program at the North Carolina Museum of Art, also in Cary, of which she
is a board member. The Goodnights had previously contributed $1 million to
create a park next to the museum where an abandoned juvenile detention center
stood. Now she plans to bring schoolchildren to enjoy the facilities and learn
about art. Because of the core-subject demands of end-of-grade testing and No
Child Left Behind, classes such as art have suffered, Ann says, who wants the
education program at the museum to be a national model.
Ann has also been busily denying recent rumors that her
ambitions for Cary extend to running for mayor. "That makes the hair on my arms
stand up," she has said. "There is absolutely no truth in this world that I
would do that." Jim Barksdale hopes to rescue his state’s economy by salvaging
its moribund public schools.
Like the Goodnights, Jim
Barksdale believes that he must save the schools before he can save the local
economy. That is why the former Netscape Communications president and CEO—who
oversaw the company’s $4.2 billion sale to AOL in 1998 during a war with
Microsoft for Internet browser dominance—now spends most of his time traversing
his home state of Mississippi to visit its notoriously underfunded public
schools, which routinely place at or near the bottom of national rankings for
math and reading scores. "I sit in the back of the room and watch and listen and
try to give some help to the team," Barksdale says. "But I’m not an expert, and
I don’t want to appear to be one or begin to think I am one."
 | | (Photograph by Greg Campbell.) | Barksdale, who grew up in Jackson, is a product of the
Mississippi school system, but he was one of the lucky students who came from
middle-class parents who instilled in him an early love of reading. He has now
adopted this mission: to improve literacy for children with the poorest reading
skills. "It’s my firm belief that if you really want to break the cycle of
poverty, the best way—the most productive way—is to improve reading scores," he
says.
Barksdale graduated from the University of Mississippi, which
is where he met his first wife, Sally; they married when they were both 21. He
then left the state to pursue the business career that made him his fortune. He
was an executive with Federal Express in Memphis and then with McCaw Cellular
Communications in Seattle. In 1996, when the couple’s three children were away
at college, Barksdale took a chance with a technology startup called Netscape,
and he and Sally moved to Palo Alto, Calif.
‘‘ It’s my firm belief that if you really want to break the cycle of
poverty, the best way is to improve reading scores.’’ | While at Netscape, Barksdale began to develop his literacy
mission. He was serving as cochair of TechNet, a network of technology company
executives concerned that their industry faced a shortage of qualified workers
because of an inadequate public school system. Discussions among the executives
spurred him to thoughts of his home state, its depressing education statistics
and the problems that in-state colleges faced retaining Mississippi’s best
students. The Barksdales went into action, making a $5.4 million donation to Ole
Miss to develop an honors college.
But Barksdale knew the state’s educational problems started
long before students reached college, and, in 2000, he partnered with the state
department of education to create a literacy program that he would fund. The
Barksdale Reading Institute began with $100 million, which to date has paid for
teaching materials and more than 6,000 books for the lowest performing public
schools in the state. Barksdale talked his younger brother, Claiborne, into
moving back to Mississippi from Atlanta, where he was working as assistant
general counsel for Bell South. Claiborne had been a teacher before he became a
lawyer, so Barksdale thought he would be perfect as the institute’s CEO.
Initially, the institute focused on reading programs for
kindergarten through third grade. Today, it employs 50 individuals—many of them
teachers—who fan out across the state to work in schools and create
individualized reading programs. The institute trains educators in local schools
and provides master-level Barksdale literacy teachers in 12 schools. The
institute also offers intervention specialists who help identify at-risk
children reading below grade level and then test the students over a three-year
period to measure improvements. "We all assume that because we can read, it
would be pretty easy to teach somebody else," Barksdale says. "These children we
are working with come from a lot of very difficult home lives, so one of the
lessons is: It’s very hard."
Barksdale has faced challenges along the way. Sally, active in
the reading program, died of colon cancer in 2003. Two years ago, Barksdale, who
has since remarried, examined the results of tests that reading specialists had
given "his" pupils, only to find that students were not moving up to their grade
level in reading quickly enough. So he expanded the program to reach children
before they entered kindergarten. "We wanted to start working with 3- and
4-year-olds because, quite often, these children never see a book or a magazine,
and they’re never read to," Barksdale says.
He has become an agitator, urging politicians and bureaucrats
to improve education funding. In 2005, Barksdale issued a challenge to state
lawmakers after reading in a newspaper that the state was unlikely to pass a
fully funded education budget. He offered a $50 million carrot in the form of
scholarships for Mississippi students. That year, lawmakers approved a $2.2
billion elementary and secondary school budget—$87.7 million shy of the
department of education’s request. The state failed to find additional funding,
and Barksdale did not provide the scholarships.
But by February of this year, Barksdale hoped that a renewed
$50 million challenge would be successful in the next legislative round. He
remains enthusiastic about bringing all Mississippi students up to grade level
in the future, despite the vast challenges. "We’re not afraid of being
disappointed. We have to face facts that it’s an enormous undertaking, and no
one’s really pulled it off yet in school districts around the country,"
Barksdale says. "I look at it in a little talk that I gave to our teachers after
one year where we didn’t get quite as far as we wanted. Look, it’s like when
they asked Edison, ‘You’ve been through 900 filaments that don’t produce light,
are you disappointed?’ He said, ‘No, I know 900 things that don’t work—that
don’t produce light.’ That’s sort of our motto."
Richard Driehaus reinvigorates the Second City one
neighborhood at a time.
Richard Driehaus was a
middle-class kid growing up in the 1950s on Chicago’s South Side when his father
commissioned an architect to design a home for a small plot of land he owned
nearby. "I remember how exciting it was to look at the plans and imagine what it
would be like," Driehaus says.
 | | (Photograph by Richard Cahan.) | The blueprints weren’t extravagant. But his father, a The blueprints weren’t extravagant. But his father, a
mechanical engineer who earned $10,700 a year, never could scrape together
enough money to build the home. The experience helped form the man Driehaus
would become: one aware of the potential beauty of urban environments—and one
determined to earn enough to keep his dreams from being deferred.
Driehaus has succeeded on both counts. The investment business
he founded in 1982, Driehaus Capital Management, has some $3.7 billion under
management; he also runs Driehaus Securities, a company started in 1979. In the
mid-1980s, he created the Richard H. Driehaus Foundation with seed capital of
$3.7 million. Today, the foundation holds nearly $70 million and has given away
close to $25 million; it distributes about $3 million a year. Two charitable
lead trusts grant another $3 million each year. Most of his philanthropy targets
the city he loves. "This is where I was born and raised," he says. "I can make
an impact here, an impact I could never have in, say, New York."
Driehaus has thrown himself into the New Millennium Park
project, for example. Mayor Richard M. Daley conceived the idea to extend
Grant Park, along Lake Michigan’s shore, and enlisted leading businesspeople to
fund the project. The resulting 24.5 acres of parkland and cultural facilities
opened in 2004 to rave reviews.
‘‘ I can make an impact here, an impact I could never have in, say, New York.’’ | To find a designer for the three-acre garden in the park,
Driehaus sponsored a competition at a cost of about $250,000. He also gave $1
million for photography exhibits in the park.
Most of Driehaus’ giving, however, focuses on
neighborhood-based initiatives where a relatively small amount of money can make
a large impact. He has given a combined $2.5 million to his alma maters, along
with dozens of smaller grants for economic development, such as his recent gift
of $25,000 for the Center for Economic Progress to fund a program to help the
working poor receive earned income tax credits. He also provided $1 million for
the renovation of Old St. Patrick’s, one of Chicago’s oldest churches. "Richard
wouldn’t say this, but he has become a major civic leader in the city, counted
on by many," Sunny Fischer, executive director of his foundation, says.
The MacArthur Fund, impressed by the foundation’s arts efforts,
gave $700,000 toward the cause, to be administered by the Driehaus Foundation.
MacArthur executives appreciated his support of smaller arts and culture groups
and theater and dance companies that often work in poor and underserved
communities.
Much of Driehaus’ strategy relies on integrating business
forces, government and public-interest groups. He remains frustrated that he
sometimes fails to find a way to bridge the three occasionally contentious
factions. His foundation created a contest to design two public schools for
severely handicapped students, but the city has yet to break ground because
of budgetary and philosophical differences between city and state funders.
Driehaus has enjoyed more success with designs for public housing. Planners are
using elements of the foundation’s public housing design competition in a
project underway in the Roosevelt Square area.
Driehaus finds the greatest satisfaction in his philanthropic
work when all the city’s forces come together to surpass the power of its parts.
"Millennium Park was a great success in that sense," he says. "It’s an example
of how politicians can encourage growth and development in a way that puts the
city back on the map." Noting that his contest brought forward a design that
another donor implemented, and that the park itself inspired the development and
renovation of many surrounding buildings, Driehaus says the Millennium Park
project shows how the best efforts take on a life of their own. Harkening back
to the thoughts of the 17th-century British architect Christopher Wren, he
notes, "Architecture strives for the everlasting." |